TAX LAW – Page 2

MRT TAX SUPPORTS VERTEX INC.

In collaboration with VATSQUARE, a leading VAT advisory Firm in the EU market, we have recently rendered advisory support to Vertex Inc on Uganda’s digital services taxation intricacies under the Value Added Tax(VAT) tax head, covering deemed supplier and foreign exchange statutory rules under the Value Added Tax Act.

Vertex Inc is a Nasdaq listed technology firm whose collaboration with tax experts and financial application technology providers across jurisdictions, delivers best in class tax technology solutions and services in global commerce.

We are honored to have contributed to the firm’s technical survey for the Ugandan tax year 2024-2025.

Tech and Automation in Tax: Key Business Insights

In my recent advisory work with a tech firm that offers tech based tax compliance tools/solutions in the international trade arena, I appreciated the extent to which automated VAT engines are becoming essential for companies operating or selling across multiple borders. These VAT engines and other tech tools ensure that businesses correctly price their products while meeting jurisdiction-specific tax obligations.

Many other technology firms are developing digital tax engines that automate tax compliance across multiple jurisdictions. These tools help businesses calculate VAT, customs duties, and even withholding taxes in real-time. Such solutions are invaluable for companies engaged in cross-border trade, where varying tax laws can create complex compliance challenges, especially for web based transactions.

However, while automation simplifies compliance, it also raises other key questions in other tax processes ancillary to compliance,

Brand Marketing and Advertising Services in Cross Border Trade; Where and How does consumption Occur for VAT Purposes?

Marketing and advertising services aim to build brand goodwill, which is an intangible asset tied to specific territories. It is obvious that brand visibility and consumer engagement occur within the market targeted by the advertisements and brand marketing, in this case, Uganda.

Goodwill, in law, is territorial and can be quantified financially but this is tied down to the territory in which the reporting entity operates because again in law, goodwill only exists with the existence of trading activities in a particular market.

This means the economic benefit sought when buying marketing services is goodwill enhancement. This economic benefit is therefore realized in the market where goodwill is enhanced as a result of the brand marketing and advertising targeting that market. In this case Uganda and most certainly not in the United States.

THE INTERPLAY BETWEEN LEGAL AND TAX IN BUSINESS TRANSACTIONS

In business, taxation is everything. As a lawyer in commercial advisory, I consider other areas of business law bridesmaids to tax as opposed to the other way round; For any business, Tax risk exposure is the most dangerous since most often it is unascertained and unknown until the taxman comes calling with an audit and there is a dispute as to whether or not tax is due. You don’t see it coming until many years later and concluded certain transactions that were not de-risked or compliance mistakes have gone burst and had the implication of putting the business on the hook for a heavy liability that was never contemplated.

THE COMPLEXITY OF TAX IS WHAT MAKES IT INTERESTING FOR PRACTITIONERS.

TAX TREATMENT OF MARKETING AND PROMOTIONS ‘FREEBEES’; LEARNING INSIGHTS FROM THE CROWN BEVERAGES CASE

In finance, a credit memo’s role is not to constitute payment for goods or services but rather to adjust accounting records to reflect a reduction in receivables. In simpler terms, a credit memo corrects or cancels a previous transaction, and as such, cannot logically be considered a form of payment for subsequent transactions

In this case, the Tribunal’s characterization of the transactions between the taxpayer and its distributor as “purchases’’ of promotional sodas and the description of the credit memo as a “form of payment” for those goods may be problematic.

The credit memo issued by Crown Beverages does not reflect a new or separate purchase. Instead, it can only be, either a reversal or adjustment of previous transactions between Crown Beverages and Lira Resort Enterprises Ltd or a promotion discount for which a promotion expense is recognised in Crown Beverages books. It can not be both.

For income tax reporting purposes, treating the credit memo as a payment method for a new separate sales transaction could lead to unintended consequences and, potentially, open up a loophole for a tax avoidance scheme.

TAX JUSTICE AND EQUITY; GOVERNMENT’S OBLIGATIONS TO TAXPAYERS.

URA ought to make reasonable accommodations for all taxpayers, recognizing that small taxpayers, in particular, may face challenges in understanding and complying with tax obligations due to limited resources and expertise. This includes providing simplified guidance, offering assistance programs, and ensuring that tax information is accessible and understandable.

Both large and small taxpayers who make genuine efforts to comply with tax laws should be treated fairly by URA. However, URA may need to exercise greater leniency and understanding towards small taxpayers who may lack the resources to fully comprehend complex tax requirements.

DISPOSAL OF REAL ESTATE ASSETS; WHEN DO WITHHOLDING TAX OBLIGATIONS ARISE?

Withholding tax on real estate transactions is advance capital gains tax on the disposal of ”business assets”. And in turn, Capital gains tax is a subcategory of business income under the Income tax Act. And finally if a transaction does not amount to a trading transaction, withholding tax under business income does not arise because the proceeds of the sale are not received as taxable income.

Taxation of Interest Income from Fixed Deposit Bank Accounts: Compliance Obligations and Related Matters.

The commercial advantages of being exempt include better cash flow and working capital management; Exempt businesses easily avoid financial distress by taking some relief from the harshness of having to pay tax before it’s due; that is to say, before the obligation to file a final return and account for income tax, arises; which for non-individuals is 6 months after the end of the tax year.

Webinar Invite: Overview of the Uganda Budget Highlights, 2024

Join us for an engaging and informative webinar where the MRT Tax and RSM Eastern Africa team will break down the Uganda Budget Highlights for 2024 and their tax and commercial implications to businesses.